A small but growing number of investors have discovered they can use the money in their IRAs to buy real estate -- from raw land to single-family homes to commercial buildings.
The rules are complex, and the stakes for running afoul of them are high. A misstep can disqualify your IRA's tax-deferred status, forcing you to pay tax on its full value plus penalties if you're under age 59½.
Owning property inside an IRA forfeits the traditional tax advantages of investing in real estate. You can't deduct property taxes or mortgage interest, and you can't use depreciation. When you sell the property, a traditional IRA turns profit into ordinary income rather than capital gains (with a Roth IRA, profit would be tax-free).
Plus, your IRA must have enough spare cash to pay such property-related expenses as maintenance costs, taxes and management fees because all income must flow into the IRA and all expenses be paid out of it.
DO YOUR HOMEWORK
Still, there are plenty of success stories. If they intrigue you, be prepared for a lot of work. First, you have to find a property you want (you can't use your IRA to purchase your own residence or vacation place). Then you have to find an IRA custodian that allows real estate investments. Don't look to your local bank or mutual fund company for help -- there are only a handful of IRA custodians who do this. You can find them by goggling for "real estate IRA" or "self-directed IRA" on the Web.
That's how Eddie Gant of Houston
found Entrust Administration (www.iraplus.com). He transferred his $150,000 IRA from his brokerage account to a Self Directed IRA last April and used $62,000 to purchase a run-down single-family home. He spent $16,000 to remodel the house and sold it within the year for $98,000. The remodeling costs came out of Gant's IRA; the profit went back in. He has since purchased three other houses with cash and estimates a minimum 50% return within one year. But Gant, 43, has a big advantage over most of us. He is a professional home remodeler.
Hanneke Jacobs of Irvine
,
Cal.
, and her husband, Peter, didn't know anything about investing in real estate when they started four years ago. But as the two of them approached 50, they knew they didn't have enough money to retire. "We didn't want to end up in a trailer park," Hanneke jokes. So on the advice of a real estate agent, they used the $100,000 in Peter's IRA as a down payment on a four-unit apartment complex. Rental income flows into the IRA, and the property has appreciated by about $200,000.
If you buy an apartment building or commercial space, you'll need to hire a property manager to collect rent and maintain the building. Depending on the IRA custodian, you may have to pay a transaction fee every time you authorize a check to pay a plumber or your property taxes.
Financing real estate inside an IRA, like the Jacobses did, adds more complexity because an individual cannot personally guarantee a loan to an IRA, and few banks will lend money to an IRA based solely on a property's potential appreciation. If you pay cash for a property, you give up the power of leverage. On the other hand, using leverage inside an IRA can trigger an arcane tax upon sale of the property on income attributed to borrowed money.
SELF DIRECTED REAL ESTATE IRAS AND 401(K)s have been in existence for almost thirty years. These are the same IRAs and 401(k)s with which everyone is familiar, with a small but important twist: these plans have an investment discretion section permitting investments in real estate, notes, options, leveraged property and more.
You can easily transfer any non self-directed IRA to a self directed IRA, or amend and restate an existing 401(k) plan to one which permits self-direction.
Find a third party administrator or a trustee in a location near you offering such diversification.
Have them simply transfer your non Self Directed IRA to a self directed IRA. If you have an old 401(k) where you used to work, you can directly roll those funds over to a Self Directed IRA.
If you are in business for yourself, you can establish a new Individual 401(k) with new generous contribution limits.
Those of you with Defined Benefits plans can just amend and restate.
You are now ready to make a number of real estate investments to build your real estate business. Invest in real property directly. You direct the administrator or trustee to use your IRA and/or 401(k) funds to invest in a property.
COMBINE YOUR IRA WITH "OTHER PEOPLE'S IRA" (OPI) funds so you can make larger purchases or a single purchase of a larger dollar amount, be it a single family dwelling, apartment complex or condo.
YOU CAN COMBINE YOUR IRA, OPI AND OTHER PEOPLE'S MONEY (OPM) to acquire the investment property. Each person receives an undivided interest in the property. All income is allocated in direct relationship to the amount invested by each person, IRA or 401(k). You can even include family members, as long as the transaction closes simultaneously.
LEVERAGE THE INVESTMENT:
You can have leveraged property in your IRA or 401(k). The loan must be non-recourse to you as an individual, and yes there are lenders who do this. Some community banks and savings associations who are portfolio lenders will make non-recourse loans on investment properties.
There may be a tax on the income on the amount financed, but the overall effect can be a real advantage to your IRA. 401(k) plan acquisition debt is not subject to any other tax, except when you receive it from your plan.
SET UP LLCS OR LAND TRUSTS AND FUND THEM WITH YOUR IRA OR PLAN FUNDS:
Your IRA or 401(k) can own interests in Limited Liability Companies or be beneficiaries of Land Trusts. These entities can then purchase investment properties.
BE A LENDER:
Your IRA, 401(k) or other plan can lend to anyone who isn't your ascendant, descendant or spouse thereof. If you have a client that needs a purchase money second, use your IRA or plan funds to finance that crucial loan to make your deal.
FINANCE OTHER PEOPLES COMMISSIONS:
If someone needs cash now, you can have your IRA or plan buy the commission.
CONSTRUCTION LOANS:
Your IRA or Plan can be a builder.
These are just a few of the methods and transactions you as a realtor can do with your IRA and 401(k) funds. In all cases, all income goes into your account and expenses associated with your property or other asset (such as accounting, property management, legal, maintenance and marketing fees) are paid from your account.
Now you have an additional source of cash to make your real estate business grow!
HISTORY OF TAX DEFERRAL IN QUALIFIED PLANS AND IRAS
In the thirty-year history of tax advantaged programs, qualified plans and individual retirement accounts have consistently been at the forefront of opportunities to defer tax. Within this context, self directed investment opportunities have not received the attention that standard IRA and Qualified Plan investments, such as stock, bonds, mutual funds and certificates of deposit, have had. Although non-standard investments in tax deferred accounts are a relatively small proportion of overall US
investments, these investments may be a significant part of anyone's diversified portfolio. Self direction of qualified plans and IRAs are straightforward as long as the IRS disqualification rules, unrelated business income tax provisions, and other related tax sections are followed.
In 1974 Congress passed the Employee Retirement Income Security Act, or ERISA, to clarify and provide non abusive circumstances under which pensions could be created. Tax advantages to the employer and employee would become available and regulated with the intent of being fair handed.
Variously known as Keogh and HR-10 plans, these eventually became known as Qualified Plans, which are employer-originated tax deferral retirement programs. (These include Defined Benefit and Defined Contribution Plans, which generally consist of Profit Sharing, with or without a 401(k) option and Money Purchase Pension Plans.)
Individual Retirement Arrangements, or IRAs, which are generally individually-originated programs, were also included in this legislation. Employer contributions to IRAs could be made following specific rules. Contributions to Qualified Plans could be made by employers to employee participants, and employees could, under specific adoption of tax code provisions, (401(k)), defer funds from their pay to their plan account. Individuals could always make contributions to their Individual Retirement Accounts provided they had earned income.
From the day the ERISA became effective, January 1, 1975, all Qualified Plans and IRA contributions and deferrals could be invested in anything permitted by law. This included any asset that could be sold or bought in the market place. The limits were and are covered by IRC Sections regarding Prohibited Transactions, Unrelated Business Income Tax and Unrelated Debt Financed Income Tax.
Because of abuse by sellers of certain investments, Congress passed legislation, effective January 1, 1981, prohibiting these investments, specifically gems, stamps, coin collections, works of art, and antiques. This legislation also permitted the deductibility of IRA contributions. Significantly, all other investment opportunities were not excluded.
The investment opportunities which became increasingly interesting to Qualified Plan and IRAs included Real Estate, Notes, Options on Real Estate, Private Placements, Investment Partnerships, and Operating Businesses.
Land, single family, multi family and commercial properties found their way into many portfolios, and the values of Plans and IRAs rose in direct proportion to property values. In some states, investments of $10,000 routinely returned $100,000 in two years. Properties being rehabilitated offer 30% returns to the savvy investor. On some occasions, options on real estate can turn a tidy profit with a very small investment. Cash flow provides many retirees tax-free income in Roth IRAs.
Plan participants and IRA owners discovered that leverage was a way to increase the income potential of land or other property. Leveraged, or debt financed property, was subject to Unrelated Business Income Tax (UBIT) rules, as was operating income generated by assets. However, acquisition debt for real estate in qualified plans is not subject to unrelated business or debt financed income tax. IRA acquisition debt for real estate was not given such generous treatment and tax payments for the debt-financed income needs to be paid by the plan or IRA.
Depreciation expense, interest expense and certain maintenance expenses are allowed as deductions on Form 990-T, Exempt Organization Business Income Tax Return, for the affected debt-financed asset or operating income asset. The implications of UBIT should be considered when making investment decisions.
Debt financing requires the services of lenders willing to lend to an IRA or plan. Non-recourse loans are the only loans permitted for plan or IRA assets. This also precludes the beneficial owner from using their credit or sign on the loan. Any extension by an IRA owner or participant of a plan to their IRA or plan is specifically prohibited. There are a number of non-recourse lenders but some diligence is necessary to find them.
Many individuals elect to partner with their plans and or IRAs, themselves and others, as undivided interests in real or other property. A growing number have established Limited Partnerships, C Corporations and Limited Liability Corporations. Each method has its advantages, depending on the situation.
STEPS TO SELF DIRECTION ARE STRAIGHTFORWARD:
- Locate a plan sponsor or IRA provider who offers completely flexible investment options in their plan and trust document.
- Adopt that plan.
- Rollover assets from any existing IRAs or past qualified plans to the new Self Directed plan.
- Determine the appropriate diversification you desire and direct the trustee or custodian to make the asset purchases on behalf of the plan or IRA.
- Income and expense are treated on a prorated basis of asset ownership and recorded accordingly.
- Distributions must be made beginning age 70 ½ for all plans other than Roth IRAs. Distributions may also be made in kind.
Congress expects the flexibility of plans and individual accounts will expand, contribution levels will increase and tax payments on new plans will be more advantageous. This will allow self direction to expand to additional plan types and generate more savings and investments. Self Directed Plans are slowly generating more interest, especially among high income, high net worth individuals, and small business owners.
Self-Direction of IRAs and plan assets is a method to increase diversification and grow retirement income. Following the rules is straightforward and, with proper assistance from tax professionals the benefits can be enormous.
PROHIBITED TRANSACTIONS
While the Internal Revenue Code and the Employee Retirement Income and Security Act (ERISA) do not state permissible retirement plan investment options, they do include what is prohibited and by whom. However, there are numerous exceptions to prohibited transactions. In addition, individuals and companies may apply for private letter rulings for unique investments not covered by the currently existing exceptions. We suggest you check with your tax advisor for specific advice.
Generally, a prohibited transaction involves the improper use of your IRA or Qualified Plan holdings by you or any disqualified person. A disqualified person is any member of your immediate family (except siblings), employers, certain partners, fiduciaries, and other categories specified in the IRS code.
IRA owners may not borrow money from their IRA, sell property to it, receive unreasonable compensation for managing it, or use it as security for a loan. Direct investment of IRA funds in collectibles, which include works of art, rugs, antiques, metals, other than gold and palladium bullion, gems, stamps, coins, except certain US minted coins, alcoholic beverages and other tangible personal property as may be defined by the Secretary of the Treasury, is also prohibited.
Qualified Plan members may not transfer Plan income or assets, sell, exchange or lease property, lend money, extend credit, furnish goods, services or facilities to disqualified persons, or allow fiduciaries to obtain or use the Plan's income or assets for their own interest.
Outside of these prohibited transactions, your investment capabilities are extensive as long as you comply with the relevant regulations.
The most frequently asked questions about self-directed retirement plans are about which kinds of transactions are permitted, and which are not. How much freedom do you have when it comes to investing with your tax-free or tax-deferred IRA?
It is interesting to note that the IRS tax code addresses this question by outlining and defining what is prohibited, or what you cannot do. Self dealing transactions are prohibited. The terms "self dealing" and "prohibited transaction" may be used interchangeably. There is little in the way of guidance or direction regarding what is allowed, in specific terms. Therefore it is important to understand the basic intent of your retirement plan, and the language that defines prohibited transactions.
Fundamentally, your retirement plan is intended to benefit you when you retire, and not before then. This simple concept is helpful in understanding the rules on permitted uses of your IRA. If you are planning any transaction which clearly appears to confer direct benefits to you prior to retirement, you should carefully examine the legality of such a transaction.
A working knowledge of several terms is invaluable in examining your options. The meanings of words like "You," "Individual Retirement Account," "Plan," "Disqualified Persons" and "Transactions" may not apply in obvious ways. Exploring these phrases in the context of this specialized subject helps to simplify things:
- "You" are not the Individual Retirement Account. You and the IRA are two entirely separate entities. You establish a trust for your benefit, through a legally permitted entity, such as a bank, savings association, or non-bank trustee. Your trustee or custodian acts on your behalf, based on your direction.
- An "Individual Retirement Account," also known as a "Plan," is a type of individual retirement arrangement which allows tax deferrals or permits tax-free accumulation of money. This account (IRA) is opened so that transactions you direct may be processed on your behalf by your trustee or custodian.
- "Transactions" are the means of moving funds into your account and making use of the funds in the account. These include contributions, purchases, sales, and distributions.
- Contributions are those transactions in which you deposit money to your account based on the legal limits in accordance with your earned income. Rollovers are a different kind of contribution that is permitted. Purchases are the acquisition of assets which you direct through your custodian or trustee. (Accounts opened with insurance companies generally purchase Individual Retirement Annuities). You may never purchase an asset and then contribute it to your IRA--purchases must be done inside your plan. Only cash may be contributed, as noted previously. Sales are transactions in which you direct your trustee or custodian to sell an asset from your account, the proceeds of which (cash or other property) remain in your account. Distributions are withdrawals from your account. You request withdrawals, in cash or in kind, from the trustee or custodian, to be made payable to you. If you ask that such withdrawal payments or assets be conveyed to a third party, it still counts as a withdrawal to you. This is very important information as regards traditional IRAs, where distributions or withdrawals are taxable events. While distributions from Roth IRAs are generally tax-free, the same principals generally apply.
By now it is clear that "You" and your IRA are different, and your trustee or custodian acts on your behalf based on your direction. By inference, it is clear that "you" never "buy" an IRA. Instead, you open an Individual Retirement Account, and then direct the purchase of an asset, which may be through the process of opening the account, or by a separate direction. A prohibited transaction is generally defined as the improper use of your IRA by you or any disqualified person.
In summary, prohibited transactions (self dealing) are those transactions that violate the basic intent of your IRA. They do not impose unacceptable limitations. On the contrary, there are numerous methods which do not violate the law that can be used to meet your long term objectives, and allow you to get the most out of your plan. A complete understanding of the applicable rules is encouraged, in order that you realize all the benefits available to you in directing your IRA
FOR IRAs, A DISQUALIFIED PERSON IS:
· the IRA holder and his or her spouse;
· the IRA holders ancestors, lineal descendants and their spouses;
· investment advisors and managers;
· any corporation, partnership, trust or estate in which the IRA holder has a 50 percent or greater interest; and
· anyone providing services to the IRA such as the trustee or custodian.
BEWARE OF THE IRS RED TAPE
One reason you probably shouldn't tackle an IRA real estate investment on your own is the IRS. The money-grabbing branch of the government has a lot of rules when it comes to using retirement funds for real estate.
"Probably the most common question I hear is, 'I've found a really neat timeshare and I want to buy it with my IRA, can I do that?' Yes, you can," says Patrick Rice of IRA Resource Associates. "Then they say, 'I want to use it for a couple weeks a year.' Well, no, you can't do that. Most calls I get, people want to buy products for their own use."
Rice says the IRS allows you to use the land or building, but not while it's in your IRA. For instance, you could buy a retirement home, rent it to someone else, put the rental income in your IRA, and, when you retire, take the house as a distribution. Then you can move in.
Just to show how complicated this can get: You cannot rent the house to your spouse or your ascendants or descendants -- grandparents, parents, children, grandchildren, etc., but you could rent it to your brother or sister while it's in your IRA.
Recent Comments